Open my Eyes...

Thoughts of an Orthodox girl from California adjusting to Manhattan life as a college student and attempting to understand her place within the Jewish people.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Eek.

This may not be the best time for me to post, but I definitely have the most time to do it right now.
So I've been back in New York for a week now. My classes are absolutely amazing; I'm such a dork, but I just love taking classes on fascinating subjects, and I'm glad to be feeling productive again.
And I can't tell you how good it feels to be back with my closest friends. I love having someone to lean on and mull things over with at the end of the day, someone who just gets what I'm trying to say, who understands me in the way that I think we all want to be understood. Thank G-d for them. I was actually kind of disappointed to be living in my own single when I first got back, just because we can't talk and talk until we're asleep. That's quickly changed, though; I love having my own personal space. It makes me feel like I've actually built my own life out here.
On that note, another thing I'm grateful for right now is the distance from the problems I was having with my family. Not that I'm ignoring what was going on in the relationship, but some healthy distance is definitely the best thing for me right now.
Alright, so I'm back and everything's great: why am I on my computer on a Sunday afternoon in the middle of Manhattan when there are endless things I could be doing?
The answer: I'm feeling down. Basically, I know that it all boils down to the fact that I'm feeling very insecure about what will become of me. Here's the thing, that may seem like a little thing, but to me its a big thing: I don't really have any close frum friends. Never have. Which certainly has a lot to do with the fact that I'm a baalas teshuvah and don't know anyone to help me break into those intimate circles, but also probably has something to do with the fact that here at school, my closest friends are certainly about as far from yiddishkeit as you can get. I'm not placing any blame for that. They're wonderful people, and I chose them.
But here's what really bugs me. The orthodox minyan at my university is notorious for being very "insider-only," unfriendly, and snooty. However, hoping that I could meet someone new at the first Friday night service of the year - assuming that there must at least be a few first-years who would be less established in the frum community than I am - I went. And it certainly lived up to my fears. Imagine: at least a hundred beautiful girls dressed for Shabbos, the men in suits, and as soon as the davening is over, they greet each other joyously, the women embrace and exchange summer stories, and welcome younger friends who are beginning their first year - and then there's you. Frozen and unsure, you realize that no one expected you; you have not a single person to approach and say "Hey, I'm Jessica, you know my cousin Yoni and blah blah blah..." You feel painfully obvious, like a phony. You weren't raised in families like theirs. You don't talk like they do. So what do you do? You quietly slip out the back door, the sounds of laughter and Shabbos lunch invitations ringing in your ears.
I plan on going to Israel for seminary next year: a very risky move on my part. This means deferring college and putting off my degree for a while (with the halfhearted agreement with my parents that I WILL come back and finish), and of course, leaving the life I've finally built here. I've never been to the Holy Land. I want to be immersed in my Jewish learning, to grow. But I'm terrified that it won't work out for me, as much as I'm terified of going alone. I mean, what Jewish girl has to deal with not knowing anyone in ISRAEL? At seminary? I fear that the entire experience will be like one, long, uncomfortable Friday night minyan, and my lack of social connections will leave me devoid of spirituality because I will be distraught and lonely. I know it might not work out like this. But these are my worries. I've already strained so many relationships with my being frum; I don't want to leave one community and never find my place in another.

13 Comments:

Blogger smb said...

It's very hard at first. I guess you just have to find the right individuals that you feel comfortable with. I remember while growing up, I didn't fit in with a lot of the girls. But later on I found some that are just right for me. I hope you find some too.

by the way, there are some nice idividuals here
that you can get to know and maybe email each other.

1:30 PM  
Blogger socialworker/frustrated mom said...

Good luck hope it gets easier.

1:32 PM  
Blogger TRW said...

I think it depends on the actual place and people. On Friday, I was waiting for a bus, sitting next to a girl. After about 7 minutes of internal debate, I turned to her and said "Hi! I'm trw!" She might have thought it was a little strange at first, but then we sat and chatted the whole busride!

I think people are afraid to take a first step, regardless of how popular they look, because they're afraid somehow that they'll be rejected..

If you want to contact me, I can try and put you in touch with some warm, welcoming people, depending on where you are.

2:35 PM  
Blogger Scraps said...

Oy, that's so rough. I know what it's like to go somewhere and feel like a complete and total outsider. It can be one of the most painful feelings, to feel utterly alone in a crowd of people you should be able to be friends with.

7:12 PM  
Blogger Scraps said...

p.s.--I don't want to post my email for fear of the spambots, but if you want my email, ask trw for it.

7:14 PM  
Blogger bamidbarminbar said...

Its a very disturbing feeling - I know exactly what you're talking about. Frankly I'm inclined to say that Hashem is only present in a community if they are acting together as a community with those ideals. Ppl are scared to take the first step? Is it not a HALACHA to say hello before the other person?

Try to feel around for a different minyan...why associate with ppl that act like that?

I once heard a Shiur about how G-d's map of Jews around the world isn't measured geographically Or by population - but my yiddishkeit. IMHO 15 friendly frum Jews is better than a community full of cold frum Jews.

9:20 PM  
Blogger Jessica said...

lvnsm27- thank you...I hope so too, and great link. I'll be sure to check it out more closely later.

socialworker/frustrated mom: thanks! :)

trw: you're right, it absolutely is the situation/people which leads to the "cold community" vibe. unfortunately, it's all i have right now. I would drop you and scraps both e-mails, but i'm not sure how.

scraps - ditto and thanks for understanding...

yakki - I very much agree with what you wrote. I have been looking around for different minyans, but I wish this one were better because everyone is my age, goes to my school, etc...it's a shame I probably won't ever know them.

10:26 AM  
Blogger Sara with NO H said...

jessica, I live in NY and I'm frum and Im going to email you. Not everyone is as stuck up as they seem...honest.

10:45 AM  
Blogger Sara with NO H said...

ok there's no email on your blog. I guess I'm not going to email you lol. You can always email me. sarasnohblog@yahoo.com

10:51 AM  
Blogger TRW said...

frumactress at gmail dot com.

:)

6:40 PM  
Blogger Scraps said...

I don't know which university you're in, but if it's either NYU or Columbia, I know a couple people I could put you in touch with (okay, one in NYU, and two in Columbia, but it's better than nothing) and they're all really nice. And I could have you over for Shabbos, too. :)

7:18 AM  
Blogger socialworker/frustrated mom said...

Anytime:)

4:44 PM  
Blogger bamidbarminbar said...

Open eyes, you've been tagged! see y4ki.blogspot.com
what is your email?

12:01 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home